VIEWS OF ILYA SHRAG ON THE JUSTICE SYSTEM IN UKRAINIAN LANDS AFTER THE JUDICIAL REFORM OF 1864.

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.31732/2708-339X-2022-03-18-23

Keywords:

lawyer, Ilya Shrag, court, Judicial reform of 1864, judicial institutions, Ukrainian lands.

Abstract

The article examines the views of the famous Ukrainian lawyer, public and socio-political figure Ilya Shrag on the justice system in Ukrainian lands after the Judicial Reform of 1864. It is noted that by the middle of the 19th century, radical changes were observed in the social and political life of the Russian Empire. The central government announced a series of reforms, including peasant, military, urban, zemstvo, and judicial reforms. It is claimed that such a need has been ripe for a long time and it has repeatedly become the subject of discussion in the highest echelons of the imperial power. Among the proposed reforms, the Judicial Reform of 1864 was the most consistent and complete. It must be stated that the relevance of the transformation of the judicial system was clearly visible in the conditions of social and political life, since the current justice system did not correspond to the peculiarities of the life of that time. The current system was not perfect, and this was repeatedly proven by judicial practice. In addition, insufficient legal qualifications of judges and bribery were observed, courts decided cases by considering only written investigation materials. It is emphasized that the analysis of the functioning of judicial institutions on the territory of Ukrainian lands occupies an important place in the creative heritage of I. Shrag. It is noted that the scientist's legal profession allowed him to investigate in detail the peculiarities of the functioning of judicial institutions, taking into account those socio-political and legal factors that significantly influenced, and often determined, the principles of the functioning of judicial institutions. It is noted that as a professional lawyer with extensive practical experience, the researcher followed in detail the functioning of the courts after their reformation during the reign of Tsar Alexander II. It is claimed that, based on the application of comparative analysis, the scientist was able to trace the peculiarities of the functioning of judicial institutions after the Judicial Reform of 1864 and up to the period of counter-reforms in the judicial sphere proclaimed by the autocracy at the end of the 19th century.

Author Biographies

V.B. Skomorovskyi, «KROK» University

doctor of legal sciences, professor, professor of the Department of Theory and History of the State and Law 

T.V. Kinzerska, «KROK» University

Postgraduate student of the Department of State Law Disciplines, assistant judge of the Sixth Administrative Court of Appeal

References

Кравчук В. М. Історико-правові аспекти основ правового статусу суддів на українських землях у складі Російської імперії (кінець XVIII – початок XX століття) // Актуальні проблеми вітчизняної юриспруденції. 2016. No 4. С. 3-7.

Люблинскій П. И. Судъ и права личности // Судебная реформа / под ред. Н. В. Давыдова и Н. Н. Полянского ; при ближайшем участии: М. Н. Гернета, А. Э. Вормса, Н. К. Муравьева и А. Н. Паренаго. 1915. Т. 2. С. 1-40.

Максимов О. В. Судова реформа на Правобережжі 1864 р.: фахова дискримінація поляків в умовах «кадрового голоду» // Intermarum. 2014. No 1. С. 124-139.

Малченко В. С. Общій очеркъ движенія гражданско-процессуальнаго законодательства послƀ 1864 года // Судебная реформа / под ред. Н. В. Давыдова и Н. Н. Полянского ; при ближайшем участии: М. Н. Гернета, А. Э. Вормса, Н. К. Муравьева и А. Н. Паренаго. 1915. Т. 2. С. 70-80.

Нестерцова-Собакарь О. В. Вплив судової реформи 1864 року на розвиток цивільного судочинства в Україні // Порівняльно-аналітичне право. 2018. No 6. С. 44-47.

Шраг І. Лист І. Дещо про Анастасьєва // І. Л. Шраг. Документи і матеріали / упор. В. М. Шевченко, Т.П. Демченко, В. І. Онищенко. Чернігів, 1997. С. 59-65.

Шраг І. Лист ІІІ // І. Л. Шраг. Документи і матеріали / упор. В. М. Шевченко, Т.П. Демченко, В. І. Онищенко. Чернігів, 1997. С. 71-82.

Шраг І. Лист VIII // І. Л. Шраг. Документи і матеріали / упор. В. М. Шевченко, Т.П. Демченко, В. І. Онищенко. Чернігів, 1997. С. 104-115.

Ярошенко М. О. Протидія корупції в судовій системі Наддніпрянської України в другій половині ХІХ – на початку XX ст. // Науковий часопис НПУ імені М. П. Драгоманова. 2015. Серія No 18. Економіка і право : зб. наукових праць. Випуск 30. C. 93-99.

Published

2023-02-19

How to Cite

Skomorovskyi, V., & Kinzerska, T. (2023). VIEWS OF ILYA SHRAG ON THE JUSTICE SYSTEM IN UKRAINIAN LANDS AFTER THE JUDICIAL REFORM OF 1864. Legal Bulletin, 18–23. https://doi.org/10.31732/2708-339X-2022-03-18-23

Issue

Section

Section I. Theory and History of Law and State